On January 9, 2025, the National Cathedral in Washington, D.C., was enveloped in a sense of reverence as attendees gathered to pay tribute to former President Jimmy Carter. At the age of 100, Carter had established a legacy that remains unparalleled in American history, being the longest-living former president. However, the memorial service became a topic of debate for reasons extending beyond his remarkable contributions to public service.
During the ceremony, close friends Garth Brooks and Trisha Yearwood delivered a rendition of John Lennon’s 1971 anthem, “Imagine.” While their sincere intentions were evident, the selection of this particular song ignited controversy on social media. Numerous fans expressed their discontent with the lyrics, especially the lines “Imagine there’s no heaven… Above us only sky,” deeming them unsuitable for a Christian funeral held in such a historic setting.
Jimmy Carter frequently expressed his admiration for John Lennon’s song “Imagine,” emphasizing its profound global influence. For Carter, the song represented a vision that transcended cultural and geographical barriers, promoting the idea of a better world. In various interviews, he referred to it as a “national anthem” in countries such as Cuba, where Lennon’s influence is particularly significant. Although the song’s message may be contentious for some, it resonated with Carter’s commitment to bridging divides and fostering mutual understanding.
The relationship between Brooks and Yearwood and the Carters extended well beyond mere friendship. They collaborated closely on numerous Habitat for Humanity initiatives, contributing to the construction of homes for families in need. Their respect for Carter’s dedication and humility was consistently evident in their public acknowledgments. During the celebration of Carter’s 100th birthday in 2024, they praised his lifelong commitment to enhancing the lives of others, referring to him as a lasting source of inspiration.
Following the passing of Rosalynn Carter in late 2023, both Brooks and Yearwood attended her memorial service to support Carter during his time of sorrow. Brooks later reflected on Carter’s remarkable resilience, highlighting his ability to inspire others even as his health waned. The couple’s relationship with the Carters was deeply founded on mutual respect and shared principles.
While the performance of “Imagine” may have elicited mixed reactions, it served to underscore the significant impact Carter had on those who knew him. For Brooks and Yearwood, it was a meaningful tribute to a man who championed the vision of a more unified world. Regardless of differing opinions on the song’s appropriateness, the tribute emphasized Carter’s enduring legacy of service, love, and hope—an influence that continues to inspire.
